13 Reasons Why Direct Mail Isn’t Dead

direct mail effectiveness

by Neil Patel


Have you ever wondered if direct mail is worth your time?

In our world of all things digital, direct mail seems old and boring.

You wouldn’t drive a horse-drawn carriage to work or use a pager to contact your friends, would you?

Of course not.

It’s for similar reasons that direct mail feels outdated.

But direct mail is still a great way to reach your audience, grab their attention, and connect with them on a personal level.

In 2016, The Data & Marketing Association reported that the direct mail customer response rate increased by 43%. Even better, the prospect response rate increased by 190% compared to 2015.

pasted image 0 754

Many marketers are in shock.

But the data is undeniable.

Direct mail is still effective and using it is a game-changer for any serious marketer.

Here are 13 reasons why direct mail still isn’t dead.

1. Direct mail has a high ROI.

Would it surprise you if I said that direct mail gives you more bang for your buck than paid search and online display ads?

Well, it does.

Direct mail has a median ROI of 29%, putting the ROI in third behind email and social media marketing. Social media is ahead by only 1 percentage point.

pasted image 0 759

That might not seem very high, but when you consider that paid search has an ROI of 23% and online display at 16%, that number looks a lot more attractive.

Are you curious about what your direct-mail ROI could become? You can go here to calculate it.

pasted image 0 733

That baffling ROI says nothing of direct mail’s response rate, which is 5.3% for mail sent to houses and 2.9% for prospect lists.

pasted image 0 720

Now compare that number to email, which has an average click-through rate of about 2% or 3%. And that’s the click-through rate, not the response rate, which is 0.6%.

Despite what people say, direct mail is still holding its own against other marketing channels.

2. Direct mail works great with a digital marketing strategy.

Every great marketing strategy uses multiple channels.

Smart marketers wouldn’t run only Facebook Ads and call it a day.

They’d consider running Instagram ads, do paid search campaigns, and even use search engine optimization to increase traffic.

While you shouldn’t invest only in direct mail, you should consider it to be part of your marketing bag of tricks.

One digital marketing company in Utah combined direct mail and digital marketing to increase loyalty with their clients.

First, they sent out a direct mailer to all of their clients with a holiday poem and a $20 bill with a scannable code next to it.

pasted image 0 770

Endearing, right? But the beauty is when you flip over the card and look at the left-hand side. There’s a scannable code and a hashtag to use below it.

pasted image 0 738

So what’s up with the $20 bill?

When someone scanned the code with their phone, it sent them to a video which encouraged them to spend $20 on someone less fortunate during the holiday season.

The agency then asked for everyone to share what they did on Twitter using the hashtag #20helps.

pasted image 0 777

Combining direct mail with savvy digital-marketing techniques increases the personability of the message you’re sending.

When you give people something to do with your direct mail, such as watching a video, taking a selfie, or spending $20, few people resist the urge to participate.

3. Direct mail can target your audience better than you might think.

On social media, targeting your audience is dead simple.

But what about sending the right message to your customers using direct mail?

Can you target your ideal client well enough to make it worth your time and money?

Yes, you can.

At USPS.com, you can use their Every Door Direct Mail tool to send mail to different customers in different areas.

USPS com Every Door Direct Mail

Start by entering your city and state or zip code.

pasted image 0 727

Hit enter. Select up to 5 zip codes near your location.

pasted image 0 747

Then click continue. You’ll see a map that looks something like this.

pasted image 0 739

When you hover your mouse over a route, the tool will show you the number of residents, number of businesses, age range, average household size, and average household income of that zone.

It even calculates the approximate cost of postage to send a mailer to that route.

Screen Shot 2017 09 04 at 1.27.13 PM 2

As long as you already know who your audience is, direct mail can be highly specific.

4. Direct mail is trackable.

Technically, there is no automatic way to track direct mail response rates, ROI, and general engagement.

Maybe a customer visits your website after seeing your direct-mail piece. While this person would count as a lead from your website, he or she should be a lead from your direct-mail campaign.

However, that does not mean you can’t track your results.

Here are a few tricks you can use to find out how well your direct-mail campaign is working.

First, if your goal is to get someone to call you, then choose a phone number that is unique to that direct-mail campaign.

10 Tips for Sending Real Estate Direct Mail with examples

Similar to this, if your goal is to get people to visit your website, you can create a unique landing page to track your results.

When people visit or click on the landing page, you’ll know that they came from that direct-mail campaign.

10 Tips for Sending Real Estate Direct Mail with examples 1

Whatever CTA you choose for your direct mail campaign, use a unique tracking device, whether that is a phone number or website URL.

Then, you can count it as a lead from your direct-mail campaign.

5. Direct mail is becoming less common.

At first glance, that might not seem like a good thing.

Maybe fewer marketers are using direct mail because it doesn’t work.

As I’ve already shown you with the above statistics, that isn’t the case.

The answer is simple. Since everyone is familiar with digital marketing, it’s easier to start getting results than doing a direct-mail campaign. So fewer people do it.

In 2016, there was a 2% decrease in direct mail delivered from the previous year.

pasted image 0 729

Why is that a good thing for your direct-mail campaign?

When fewer marketers are sending mail, your piece has a higher chance of standing out.

Think about how much harder it is today to rank in Google. If I type in, “how to send awesome direct mail,” Google only shows me 10 results out of 6,470,000 possible answers.

how to send awesome direct mail Google Search

In other words, the internet is full of marketing messages.

But mailboxes aren’t.

And that’s why direct mail still works so well in this digital age. Since it takes a bit more work than other digital marketing strategies, it’s less common and thus more effective.

6. Direct mail has a feeling of romanticism.

Like hot baths and candlelit dinners, direct mail has become romanticized in our culture.

Think about it. When you receive a handwritten letter from someone, what do you do?

You get excited. Someone cares enough to write you a letter. It’s not very often that you receive something like this.

What do you do next?

I’ll bet you sit down and read every word of that letter. But it’s not just you who loves getting letters.

73% of people said that they prefer direct mail as an advertising method.

pasted image 0 724

And 57% of people said that receiving mail makes them feel valued.

pasted image 0 734

Since people are receiving less and less mail, each piece of mail is more exciting.

Especially if your direct mail is handwritten. Even if you simply add your signature.

In a world where everything gets written by a machine, handwriting on a direct-mail piece is a touch that receivers won’t be able to ignore.

Just check out this example from BiggerPockets.

pasted image 0 722

It’s more like getting a personal letter from a friend than a marketing message from a business.

7. Direct mail is tangible.

Imagine this. You receive a coupon in the mail for $10 off your next meal at your favorite local pub.

pasted image 0 744

If you’re like me, you set the coupon on your refrigerator for future use.

Then, you pretty much forget about it. For the next few weeks, the coupon sits in your kitchen with other unused direct-mail offers.

But one night, your buddy calls and wants to watch the big game at a restaurant. As you’re trying to decide where to go, you remember, “Oh! I have a coupon to our favorite pub.”

And at that moment, the coupon makes the decision for you.

Even though the coupon is for just $10.

You could do the same thing with a haircut business.

pasted image 0 749

Or an eCommerce store. No brick-and-mortar location needed.

pasted image 0 772

Since direct mail is tangible, it sticks around. It clutters physical space.

Email is easy to forget about because it’s just a number on a screen, but mail is unavoidable.

About 66% of people have purchased a product because of direct mail.

If your direct mail piece has a special offer, most people will save it for future use, and then they won’t be able to forget about it.

8. Direct mail gets undivided attention.

A certain fear accompanies direct mail.

What do I mean?

When you open the mailbox and pull out a small stack of letters, you won’t throw away any of the mail without at least glancing at it first.

You don’t immediately know which piece of mail requires your attention and which one you’re uninterested in. There is a fear that you might miss out on something important.

Because of that, you don’t want to throw mail away without taking a peek at it first.

80% of direct mail recipients scan or read each piece before throwing anything away.

pasted image 0 723

The point?

When you receive an email, there are at least four (or forty) other tabs open on your computer. There are a bunch of notifications dinging on your phone and laptop.

But when you receive a piece of direct mail, you’re at home, after work, with some extra time to view each letter.

Direct mail naturally gets more attention because there are fewer distractions when people see it.

9. Direct mail increases your brand awareness.

As I’ve shown you, direct mail is tangible, meaning it has the potential to stick around for a long time in someone’s house.

For this reason, consistent mailing increases awareness of your brand.


Consider this piece of direct mail from Le Tote.

pasted image 0 752

The front has the value proposition and offer, while the back demonstrates how easy it makes your life.

pasted image 0 731

Since this postcard offers a coupon, there’s a good chance that the recipients will save it for a later date.

But what if they don’t use it later?

What if they see it, read it, and then throw it away?

Did you just lose money on a poor direct-mail campaign?

Not necessarily.

Sure, your recipients might not have an interest in your offer right now. But they saw your logo, your brand name, and what you do.

If there comes a day when they want your product, they might just visit your website and buy something from you.

Before the direct mail piece, there was no chance of that because they didn’t know who you were.

And that’s a win for any marketer.

10. Direct mail is for all age groups.

I consider this one of the most compelling reasons that direct mail still isn’t dead.

If you send an email, use Facebook Ads, or do any online marketing, your chance of reaching an older demographic isn’t good.

Only 59% of people between ages 65 and 69 own a smartphone. That percentage decreases all the way to 17% as the age increases.

pasted image 0 762

Similarly, an average of only 67% of people between ages 65 and 80 have the Internet, and that percentage decreases all the way to 44% with age.

pasted image 0 735

Finally, an average of 34% of people between ages 65 and 80 use social media, with a low percentage sitting at a measly 17%.

pasted image 0 780

Conversely, direct mail reaches everyone, the young, and the old alike. Everyone checks the mail, and because of that, your postcards and coupons can turn anyone into a customer.

11. Direct mail is creative.

When it comes to direct mail and creativity, the sky’s the limit.

Because direct mail is a physical product, sending stuff that stands out is just a matter of having fun with it.

This example from ADT is a bit controversial in its execution. But it’s a great example of creative direct-mail marketing in action.

pasted image 0 742

Here’s how it works.

A letter-sized card slides under the door to the house of the receiver. But the letter is carefully engineered to pop-up into a box once it’s under the door.

On the box it reads, “Breaking into your apartment is easier than you think.”

When someone sees it, they might immediately think, “What the… Did someone break into my house?!”

ADT highlighted a problem in action. What’s a good solution? Get an ADT security system.

On the less controversial side of things, a gym in Brazil was struggling with members quitting because they didn’t see immediate results from their workouts.

As a reminder that getting results takes consistent time in the gym, they sent out calendars to their members that illustrated the gradual progress that they’d see if they stick with the program.

pasted image 0 732

Coming up with flashy ideas is not easy. If you’re not naturally creative, then talk with someone who is.

If a security-system brand and a gym can come up with interesting direct-mail pieces, the chances are that you can too.

It might just take a little extra thought.

12. Direct mail is multi-sensory.

With digital marketing, it’s impossible to hit all of the senses and difficult to hit more than two.

The five senses are touch, hearing, sight, taste, and smell.

At most, a digital campaign can only focus on sight and hearing. By making a digital ad interactive, some smart marketers can appeal to someone’s sense of touch. But even that experience is not the same.

By making a digital ad interactive, some smart marketers can appeal to someone’s sense of touch. But even that experience is not the same.

Everyone experiences the world through their senses. Direct mail can take advantage of all 5 of them.

George Patterson Y&R Melbourne sent out a cardboard box with two knobs on it and a baggy of electronic components. It included everything necessary to build an FM radio.

Everything, except for one thing: instructions.

pasted image 0 740

The mail piece went out to college engineering students.

When they put together the radio, an ad played offering the student a fast track to an exciting career in the military.

Talk about multi-sensory. This cardboard radio took advantage of three senses, and some might argue 4 with the smell of cardboard.

Consider this KitKat mailer.

pasted image 0 765

This direct mail piece acts as if you ordered a KitKat to your mailbox, implying that it was too “chunky” to arrive at your home.

Although there are technically only two senses involved, sight and touch, this piece does a good job of trying to include taste by emphasizing the “chunky”-ness of a KitKat.

Not to mention, it’s fully interactive as you walk to the store.

Because humans experience the world through five senses, the more of these that your direct mail activates, the more likely that recipients will engage with your message.

13. Direct mail is memorable.

Imagine putting together a radio delivered to your mailbox.

Maybe you receive a box near your door that reads, “Breaking into your house is easy.”

Or you get a funny mailer from KitKat that says your candy bar was too “chunky” to arrive at your home.

Or you get a tiny record player in the mail.

pasted image 0 721

If you’re like most people, you’ll tell your friends about these memorable pieces of marketing genius.

Because direct mail is tangible and endlessly creative, it sticks with your audience.

As long as you take the time to put together an amazing piece of direct mail, your audience won’t quickly forget the message you sent.


Despite the belief that direct mail is dead, it couldn’t be more alive.

In fact, the expanding practice of digital marketing has only enhanced the return on investment you can get from a successful direct mail campaign sent to your customers.

If you’re wondering why direct mail should take a place in your marketing tool belt, the above 13 reasons are answer enough.

Direct mail campaigns give a high ROI and even a higher ROI than paid ads. They can work effectively in a campaign by themselves, or alongside a digital-marketing campaign.

You can use direct mail to target the right customers at the right time. And it’s easy to track the results of each campaign you run.

With direct mail becoming less common, there is less noise. You can capture the undivided attention of your customers with its romantic appeal.

Because direct mail is more likely to get read, it increases your brand awareness, even if the first letter is unsuccessful.

Unlike digital campaigns, direct mail has a larger appeal to every age group.

Since direct mail is a physical product, it allows room for you to be more creative. Thus it can appeal to more senses, leaving a lasting and memorable impact on your customer.

In the end, direct mail is powerful because it’s different from the digital way of doing things.

I get hundreds of emails every week. But I get a fraction of that number in the form of letters in my mailbox.

To stand out in a world where everything has gone electronic, consider complementing your digital marketing strategy with a direct-mail campaign.

It’s a missing personal touch in an incredibly busy world.

And as every great marketer knows, being personal pays off.

What is the biggest reason you think that direct mail is still going strong?



Go to our website:   www.ncmalliance.com


  1. Lots of good suggestions there. For sending handwritten cards or notes, referenced in #6, you might want to check out Thankster.com. It lets you automate the process by integrating it with your CRM or other software or apps. Or we can help you with one-off projects and custom cards. You can contact us for more info via the contact form at Thankster.com. Or go to bit.ly/postsamp to get a free sample.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s